Most Favored Nation Clause In Healthcare Payer Contracting
A most favored nation clause in healthcare payer contracting is a contractual provision requiring a healthcare provider to offer a payer prices or terms at least as favorable as those offered to any other payer under similar circumstances.
What is a Most Favored Nation Clause In Healthcare Payer Contracting?
A most favored nation clause in healthcare payer contracting is a contractual provision between a healthcare provider and a payer (like an insurance company) that typically requires the provider to give the payer the lowest reimbursement rate they offer to any other payer for the same services. These clauses are designed to ensure that the contracting payer receives the most favorable rates, preventing the provider from charging a competitor less. Proponents argue that MFN clauses can help health insurers lower the cost of their products by reducing the purchase cost of medical care. However, the use of MFN clauses has been controversial and has faced scrutiny for potential anticompetitive effects, such as limiting competition among carriers or providers.
The MFN clause in this context is distinct from its common usage in international trade, although the principle of non-discriminatory, most-favorable treatment remains similar. Variations exist, such as "Ceiling" MFN clauses, which guarantee that the payer demanding the MFN is not paying reimbursement *above* the rates of any other payer, rather than guaranteeing the absolute lowest price. Regulators sometimes examine MFN clauses to determine if they are anticompetitive, taking into account factors like the impact on competition, quality and availability of healthcare services, and the price and stability of health insurance for consumers.
What is the difference between a Most Favored Nation Clause In Healthcare Payer Contracting and Ceiling MFN clause?
The standard Most Favored Nation (MFN) clause typically requires a healthcare provider to give a payer the absolute lowest reimbursement rate offered to any other payer for the same services. The Ceiling MFN clause is a variation that ensures the contracting payer is not paying reimbursement above the rates of any other payer, rather than guaranteeing the absolute lowest price.
The standard MFN clause guarantees the contracting payer the lowest reimbursement rate offered by the provider to any other payer.
The Ceiling MFN clause guarantees that the contracting payer is not paying reimbursement above the rates of any other payer, which is a less stringent requirement than the absolute lowest price.
What are examples of a Most Favored Nation Clause In Healthcare Payer Contracting?
A large insurance company requires a hospital system to agree that the negotiated reimbursement rate for common procedures will not be higher than the rate the hospital offers to any other commercial insurer. This is a standard MFN clause ensuring the insurer gets the best price.
A state regulatory body investigates an MFN clause in a contract between a dominant health plan and a major provider group because competitors complain the clause makes it impossible for them to negotiate lower rates, potentially leading to an antitrust violation.
A 'Ceiling' MFN clause is used where a small insurance payer only requires that the provider's rate to them is not *above* the rate given to the largest payer in the region, rather than demanding the absolute lowest rate offered to anyone.
Let's review your payer contracts side-by-side with the market.
Bring your top billing codes and we'll show you how you compare to your peers in 15 minutes or less.