PayerPrice
Data Platform
More
Check Local Rates
Short Term Acute Care HospitalVoluntary Non-Profit - Church

Good Samaritan Hospital

Catholic Health Services of Long Island · West Islip, NY

1000 Montauk Highway, West Islip, NY 11795(631) 376-3000

3 of 5

CMS star rating

458

Beds

27,021

Inpatient discharges a year

$922.7M

Net patient revenue a year

35

In-network payers

About this hospital

Good Samaritan Hospital is a 458-bed voluntary non-profit - church hospital in West Islip, NY, affiliated with Catholic Health Services of Long Island. Below you'll find publicly disclosed negotiated rates and facility details, including 35 in-network payers and 392 disclosed rate categories.

  • Rural referral center
  • Reclassified as rural
  • Disproportionate share hospital
  • 340B participant
CCN
330286
NPI
1902865355
Health system
Catholic Health Services of Long Island
Teaching
Teaching hospital
County
Suffolk County
Metro area
New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ MSA
Medicare contractor
Jurisdiction K, National Government Services (13001)
In Medicare since
1966
Last CMS survey
2023

Prices for common services

The 24 services Good Samaritan Hospital most likely performs, ranked by likely volume and what it is paid. Each service names one insurer. * marks hidden insurer names; A, B and C rank the remaining rates from low to high and reset for each service.

Book a demo to see hidden insurer names, more payer rates, and hospital data, or start a free trial.

Childbirth · Inpatient

Vaginal delivery, hospital stay

MS-DRG 807

$10,725 - $13,814

from 4 insurers · median $12,362

UnitedHealthcare$10,725
Insurer A*$11,825
Insurer B*$12,900
Insurer C*$13,814

CMS lists this service as CPT 59400, the obstetrician's global fee. The hospital bills the delivery stay as MS-DRG 807, so these are facility case rates.

Hospital reports neonatal nursery services to CMS

Childbirth · Inpatient

Cesarean delivery, hospital stay

MS-DRG 788

$14,659 - $19,330

from 4 insurers · median $16,775

UnitedHealthcare$14,659
Insurer A*$16,514
Insurer B*$17,035
Insurer C*$19,330

CMS lists this service as CPT 59510, the obstetrician's global fee. The hospital bills the delivery stay as MS-DRG 788, so these are facility case rates.

Hospital reports neonatal nursery services to CMS

Gynecology

Hysteroscopy with sampling of the uterine lining

CPT 58558

$2,701 - $4,753

from 4 insurers · median $3,776

Aetna$2,701
Insurer A*$3,723
Insurer B*$3,829
Insurer C*$4,753
Medicare $3,847Nearby hospitals $7,21148% below nearby hospitals

85 Medicare claims in Level 4 Gynecologic Procedures (CMS 2024)

Medicine & Surgery · Inpatient

Spinal fusion except cervical without MCC

MS-DRG 460

$57,819 - $92,814

from 4 insurers · median $72,543

Aetna$77,203
Insurer A*$57,819
Insurer B*$67,882
Insurer C*$92,814
Medicare $29,021Nearby hospitals $84,84314% below nearby hospitals

28 Medicare discharges for this DRG in CMS hospital data

How the insurers pay at Good Samaritan Hospital

Median rate as a percent of Medicare across the outpatient services above, and how many services sit above or below the same insurer's median at nearby hospitals. * marks hidden insurer names. These table labels track the same insurers across services; the labels on each service card reset.

InsurerServicesMedian % of MedicareAbove nearbyBelow nearby
Insurer A*24
224%
412
Insurer B*24
223%
99
Insurer C*24
221%
64
Insurer D*24
131%
021

How we chose these services: 6 appear in this hospital's own Medicare claims, 13 are common here based on CMS Medicare volume, and 5 are typical for the service lines it reports to CMS. Rates come from insurer and hospital price transparency files as of October 2026. Rates under a quarter of Medicare or over 20 times Medicare are left out as likely physician-fee rows or file errors. Book a demo to see all 300 CMS shoppable services for Good Samaritan Hospital, or start a free trial.

Insurance Accepted

Acceptance varies by plan and service. Confirm coverage with your insurer or the hospital's billing department.

Medicare
Aetna
BCBS
Cigna
United Healthcare (incl Optum, Rocky Mountain, Health Plan of Nevada, Sierra Health)
Ameri HealthAspirus Health PlanAvera Health PlansBanner HealthCenteneEmblemHealth

More about this hospital

  • Quality

    3 of 5 stars

    • 224 min in the ER before going home (US median 148)
    • Medicare readmissions penalty (-0.08%)
    See quality ratings
  • Doctors and services

    Accredited by The Joint Commission

    • Teaching hospital
    • 43 services, including trauma care
    • 1,203 affiliated clinicians
    See doctors and services
  • Finances

    $922.7M net patient revenue

    • Operating margin on patient care -6.1%
    • $47.6M unreimbursed and uncompensated care
    • $16.7M net income
    See finances
  • Ownership and leadership

    Owned by Catholic Health System of Long Island Inc

    • Private (not for profit)
    • Patrick M O'Shaughnessy, chief executive
    • 340B drug pricing program participant
    See ownership and leadership

Tax IDs and NPIs insurers list

The employer identification numbers (EINs) health plans and networks list for Good Samaritan Hospital in the in-network rate files they publish, with the organization NPIs billed under each.

Tax ID (EIN)Plans and networks listing itOrganization NPIs
11-1888924Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center57Aetna, Cigna, United Healthcare (incl Optum, Rocky Mountain, Health Plan of Nevada, Sierra Health), Allied Benefit Systems, Aspirus Health Plan and 52 more1902865355 Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center1275529612 Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center1548501620 Good Samaritan Hospital Medicaland 25 more

Source: PayerPrice analysis of insurers' Transparency in Coverage in-network files. An EIN can cover several hospitals and clinics in a health system, and insurers sometimes list other organizations' NPIs under it.

Location

1000 Montauk Highway, West Islip, NY 11795

(631) 376-3000

Get directions

Frequently asked questions

About Good Samaritan Hospital's rates and hospital price transparency.

How much does an MRI cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For MRI brain before and after contrast (CPT 70553), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $343 to $828 across 4 insurers. Blue Cross Blue Shield's rate is $820. The median at nearby comparable hospitals is $847. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

How much does a CT scan cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For CT abdomen and pelvis with contrast (CPT 74177), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $521 to $828 across 4 insurers. Blue Cross Blue Shield's rate is $684. The median at nearby comparable hospitals is $722. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

How much does a colonoscopy cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For Colonoscopy with biopsy (CPT 45380), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $2,473 to $3,797 across 4 insurers. Cigna's rate is $2,656. The median at nearby comparable hospitals is $3,462. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

How much does giving birth cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For Vaginal delivery, hospital stay (MS-DRG 807), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $10,725 to $13,814 across 4 insurers. UnitedHealthcare's rate is $10,725. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

How much does a mammogram cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For Screening mammography, bilateral (CPT 77067), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $195 to $449 across 4 insurers. UnitedHealthcare's rate is $217. The median at nearby comparable hospitals is $219. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

How much does hip or knee replacement cost at Good Samaritan Hospital?

For Major lower-extremity joint replacement without MCC (MS-DRG 470), published negotiated rates at Good Samaritan Hospital range from $33,313 to $49,736 across 4 insurers. Aetna's rate is $41,500. The median at nearby comparable hospitals is $51,640. What a patient pays depends on their plan's deductible, coinsurance and network status.

What is Good Samaritan Hospital's CMS star rating?

Good Samaritan Hospital has a CMS overall hospital star rating of 3 out of 5 on Medicare Care Compare (CMS data released 2026-08-13). That is lower than 42% of US hospitals.

Is Good Samaritan Hospital a teaching hospital?

Yes. CMS counts 0.09 Medicare-funded residents per bed at Good Samaritan Hospital for fiscal year 2027, so it is a teaching hospital.

Does Medicare penalize Good Samaritan Hospital for readmissions?

Yes. Under the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, Medicare cuts Good Samaritan Hospital's base inpatient payments by an estimated 0.08% in fiscal year 2027 for more readmissions than expected.

What are the most common Medicare inpatient stays at Good Samaritan Hospital?

In 2024, the most common were septicemia or severe sepsis without mv >96 hours with mcc (556 discharges), heart failure and shock with mcc (234 discharges), percutaneous and other intracardiac procedures without mcc (164 discharges).

For hospital finance and compliance teams

Running price transparency at a hospital like this one?

The data on this page comes from the files hospitals and payers publish. We help hospitals publish theirs correctly, and take a fresh look at their chargemaster.

Compliance MRF

Publish a CMS-compliant machine-readable file

We turn your chargemaster and payer contracts into the CMS template file, then keep it current as rates change.

CMS v3 example: standard_charge_information[0]
{
  "description": "MRI of brain (no contrast)",
  "code_information": [
    { "code": "611", "type": "RC" },
    { "code": "70551", "type": "CPT" }
  ],
  "standard_charges": [{
    "setting": "outpatient",
    "minimum": 250,
    "maximum": 400,
    "gross_charge": 1200,
    "discounted_cash": 1080,
    "payers_information": [
      {
        "payer_name": "Platform Health Insurance",
        "plan_name": "PPO",
        "methodology": "fee schedule",
        "standard_charge_dollar": 400
      },
      {
        "payer_name": "Region Health Insurance",
        "plan_name": "HMO",
        "methodology": "fee schedule",
        "standard_charge_dollar": 250
      }
    ]
  }]
}
  • CMS template layout, in JSON or CSV
  • Gross, discounted cash, payer-specific and de-identified min / max charges
  • cms-hpt.txt file and homepage footer link
  • Refreshed when your contracts change
Talk to us about your MRF
Chargemaster analysis

Get your chargemaster right for billing and payer contracts

Your chargemaster sets the gross charge on every claim, and many payer contracts base payment on it through percent-of-charge, lesser-of and stop-loss terms. We audit it line by line and show how your charges and negotiated rates compare with peer hospitals before your next negotiation.

What a review covers

CodingPricingPayer contractsCompliance
  • CPT, HCPCS, revenue code and modifier errors flagged line by line
  • Missing, duplicate and outdated charge lines identified
  • Charges set below payer allowables caught before lesser-of clauses cut payment
  • Revenue impact of charge changes modeled across percent-of-charge and stop-loss terms
  • Your negotiated rates benchmarked against peer hospitals for the same payers
Talk to us about your chargemaster